Legal identity of flora and fauna in India – By SOHINI BISWAS

Coming back to the present times, it is evident that in this age of modernity, the trends in environmental jurisprudence are also changing. This change has been witnessed throughout the world.
The first country to provide rights to nature was Ecuador. It provided nature with the right to persist, exist, function, regenerate and evolve its vital cycles. Similarly, laws on the rights of Mother Nature were made by Bolivia in 2010. These included rights are given to the environment for protection degradation and monetary exploitation.
Te Urewera National park of New Zealand was given the status of a legal entity in 2014 by the New Zealand legislature. This national park now possesses all rights, duties and liabilities like a legal person. Whanganui River of New Zealand was also recognized as a legal person having all rights and duties. Over a 140 year-long litigation, it was proved by the Maori Tribe that this river is their ancestor and hence to be protected as other members of the tribe.
Can animals be regarded as person – perspective of the Indian judiciary
The Indian judiciary has witnessed several cases, which has led to the development of the jurisprudence concerning animal rights and their status as a person. The following is an enumeration of all the important judgements of the Indian courts, marking the evolution in animal rights in the country-
Animal Welfare Board of India v. A. Nagaraja and Others
This case, often known as the Jallikattu case, initiated debates in the whole country. This case dates back to 2011, when the Ministry of Environment and Forest amended section 22 of the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, to include bulls and hence banning their taming, training and exhibition. However, the government proposed to create an exception for the bulls participating in Jallikattu.
Jallikattu is a collection of events which aim at taming bulls. Animal Welfare Board of India investigators had reported that PCA Act is violated in almost all steps of this “ Bull Training” event. The animals are subjected to inhumane conditions and brutal taming practices. This includes beating, putting irritants in their eyes, making them drink alcoholic fluids, use of painful and brutal rectaring methods etc.
Animal Welfare Board of India contended that there were no justifiable grounds on which this exception was made. It was contended that this was no unavoidable activity, rather it only causes graver pain and suffering to innocent animals.
In this case, the court gave a judgement in favour of the Animal Welfare Board of India, holding that this activity of bull-taming was not at all necessary, rather it added to pain, anxiety and suffering of animals. This event, held solely for human pleasure, has to be avoided.
The court, in this case, made an important observation that Article 21 of the Constitution of India, ensures the right to life and liberty not just to human beings, but to animals also.
Karnail Singh and Others v. the State Of Haryana
This case was brought before the high court of Punjab and Haryana, by individuals who were convicted for illegal trade of cows from Haryana. The conviction was upheld by the court, however, the prison sentence was not meted out.
The court pronounced the following important points in this case-
1. It was ruled that all species of the animal kingdom are to be accorded with rights and duties. Each animal has a distinct legal identity with all rights and liabilities as are possessed by any other person. It was also held in this case that the duty that people have towards the protection of minor children extends to animals as well.
2. It was held that all animal species were to be treated with respect. They have an inherent right to live which is to be protected by law. Also, the privacy of animals is to be protected from unlawful attacks.
3. Certain mandatory directions were also issued by the court for the welfare of animals.
4. The government of Haryana was directed to ensure that animals should not carry more weight than what was the prescribed limit. This weight was to be changed with the change in terrain, where these animals are carrying this weight. For example, the weight is to be reduced by 50 per cent, if there is an ascent route.
5. It was also made clear that a total of four people excluding the driver and children below six years of age could ride an animal-driven vehicle.
6. It was ruled that the use of shard things over animals was banned throughout the state of Haryana.
7. Lastly, various directions about veterinary care, housing, and food for animals were issued by the court in its detailed judgement.
Recognized of plants as legal persons under law
Animal’s right to be recognised as a legal person has been given much more emphasis than the grant of a similar right to plants. This is true for the whole world and specifically for India. However, a recent judgement by the Uttarakhand high court has granted this much-needed right to the whole of the ecosystem.
In the case of Lalit Miglani v. State of Uttarakhand, the High Court of Uttarakhand gave the legal status of a person to river Ganga and its tributary Yamuna. This was pronounced in a short judgment which was followed by a detailed order specifying the intricacies of rights granted to the whole ecosystem. In the subsequent order, it was stated that it would be impossible to protect one aspect of the environment without protecting the other and hence the whole ecosystem was granted the status of a legal person.
This judgement has some major lacunas. The foremost question that crops up is who shall be held responsible in case the rights of ecosystems are affected? Also, the judgement does not provide specifications regarding which components of the ecosystem are protected. This broad order has attracted much ambiguity. However, this has to be taken into consideration that this is the only judgement which addresses the issue of the providence of the legal status of a person to plants. There is no legislation in India on this issue. Therefore it is evident that much legal research is required to address this issue, the Uttarakhand judgement is only a baby step towards the achievement of this objective.
There is an urgent need for integration of the concept of environmental personhood into the constitutional set up of our country. However, with these various questions crop up. The first one being, even if they are provided with a legal statue of a person, who will represent and protect their rights? More importantly what would be the norms or rules with which these representatives would be bound. One solution proposed is the reservation of seats in the national and state legislature of each ecosystem. These could be represented by communities specific to that ecosystem. This is only a farfetched solution before these rules and regulations have to be formulated by the Indian legislature for the protection of nature.

Leave a Reply


Troy Aikman CBD Gummies (Scam Or Trusted) Beware Before Buying

If you have any desire to work on your psychological and actual wellbeing, you can beyond a shadow of a doubt trust Troy Aikman CBD Gummies. Assuming you consume biting gum in the perfect sum, you can work on your way of life. The most outstanding aspect of gummies is that they are 100 percent regular […]

Read More

Troy Aikman CBD Gummies (Scam Exposed) Ingredients and Side Effects

Troy Aikman CBD Gummies are a reasonable extraordinary and hearty course of activity. They incorporate present day and standard adornments to address or fix logical issues. You need to kill the cannabinoids from the plant with exorbitant mindfulness. It very well might be joined with first rate trimmings to make it extra enormous and taste […]

Read More

#1 Shark-Tank-Official Sweet Relief CBD Gummies – FDA-Approved

Sweet Relief CBD Gummies are packed with clean and natural active ingredients to keep the human body healthy and stimulated for normal functions, as well as to reduce pain and discomfort caused by problems. This pure and organic CBD supplement removes many impurities from the human body as well as allows the human body to do […]

Read More