Collegium System for the Appointment of Judges By Jai Sikand

Why in News

Recently, the Supreme Court (SC)questioned the government about the delay in clearing Collegium recommendations for judicial appointments to various High Courts (HC).

Key Points

  • Collegium System:
    • It is the system of appointment and transfer of judges that has evolved through judgments of the SC, and not by an Act of Parliament or by a provision of the Constitution.
      • Evolution of the System:
        • First Judges Case (1981):
          • It declared that the“primacy” of the Chief Justice of India (CJI)srecommendation on judicial appointments and transfers can be refused for “cogent reasons.”
          • The ruling gave the Executive primacy over the Judiciary in judicial appointments for the next 12 years.
        • Second Judges Case (1993):
          • SC introduced the Collegium system,holding that “consultation” really meant “concurrence”.
          • It added that it was not the CJI’s individual opinion, but an institutional opinion formed in consultation with the two senior-most judges in the SC.
        • Third Judges Case (1998):
          • SC on President’s reference expanded the Collegium to a five-member body,comprising the CJI and four of his senior-most colleagues.
    • The SC collegium is headed by the CJI and comprises four other senior most judges of the court.
    • A HC collegium is led by its Chief Justice and four other senior most judges of that court.
      • Names recommended for appointment by a HC collegium reaches the government only after approval by the CJI and the SC collegium.
    • Judges of the higher judiciary are appointed only through the collegium system and the government has a role only after names have been decided by the collegium.
      • The government’s role is limited to getting an inquiry conducted by the Intelligence Bureau (IB) if a lawyer is to be elevated as a judge in a High Court or the Supreme Court.
        • Intelligence Bureau (IB): It is a reputed and established intelligence agency. It is authoritatively controlled by the Ministry of Home Affairs.
      • It can also raise objections and seek clarifications regarding the collegium’s choices, but if the collegium reiterates the same names, the government is bound, under Constitution Bench judgments, to appoint them as judges.
  • Procedure for Various Judicial Appointments:
    • For CJI:
      • The President of India appoints the CJI and the other SC judges.
      • As far as the CJI is concerned, the outgoing CJI recommends his successor.
      • In practice, it has been strictly by seniority ever since the supersession controversy of the 1970s.
    • For SC Judges:
      • For other judges of the SC, the proposal is initiated by the CJI.
      • The CJI consults the rest of the Collegium members, as well as the senior-most judge of the court hailing from the High Court to which the recommended person belongs.
      • The consultees must record their opinions in writing and it should form part of the file.
      • The Collegium sends the recommendation to the Law Minister, who forwards it to the Prime Minister to advise the President.
    • For Chief Justice of High Courts:
      • The Chief Justice of High Court is appointed as per the policy of having Chief Justices from outside the respective States.
      • The Collegium takes the call on the elevation.
      • High Court judges are recommended by a Collegium comprising the CJI and two senior-most judges.
      • The proposal, however, is initiated by the outgoing Chief Justice of the High Court concerned in consultation with two senior-most colleagues.
      • The recommendation is sent to the Chief Minister, who advises the Governor to send the proposal to the Union Law Minister.
  • Criticism of the Collegium System:
    • Opaqueness and a lack of transparency.
    • Scope for nepotism.
    • Embroilment in public controversies.
    • Overlooks several talented junior judges and advocates.
  • Attempts to reform the Appointment System:
  • Way Forward

    • Filling up of vacancies is a continuous and collaborative process involving the executive and the judiciary, and there cannot be a time frame for it. However, it is time to think of a permanent, independent body to institutionalize the process with adequate safeguards to preserve the judiciary’s independence guaranteeing judicial primacy but not judicial exclusivity.
      • It should ensure independence, reflect diversity, demonstrate professional competence and integrity.
    • Instead of selecting the number of judges required against a certain number of vacancies, the collegium must provide a panel of possible names to the President to appoint in order of preference and other valid criteria.

Topic – Collegium System for the Appointment of Judges

By Jai Sikand AT LEXCLIQ

 

Leave a Reply

LexCliq

601 fotbollströjor online VRVAdr

. Carragher gick sedan vidare och insisterade på att det inte spelar någon roll hur bra Haaland kan bli, det var inte rätt affär för United. Enligt uppgift beslutade Woodward att avtalet gick ut eftersom Haalands agent Mino Raiola krävde för mycket och Carragher sa till The Telegraph att han tycker att Woodward ringde rätt. […]

Read More
LexCliq

Sky Sports Action & Arena – Real Time NFL, NBA, Rugby Union, Rugby League & Much More

The functions and also features of the marvelous residential task are primary accessibility road, main entry gate, main park, running track, multi-purpose floor, marsh playground, picnic lawn, family pavilion, home seats area, future advancement, bird witnessing epidermis, tennis court, festal court, baseball judge, toddler play area, club, pool, swimming pool with deck. Not many project […]

Read More
LexCliq

World Cup 2021 Face Painting Ideas

The £17m signing has excited fans with his electric performances and it is hoped more will get the chance to watch him from the stands next season. The forward’s experience has been invaluable for United’s younger players and they will have another season to learn from the Uruguayan after he signed a one-year contract extension […]

Read More